| Sam Muchnick | 1992 |
| Lou Thesz | 1992 |
| George Hackenschmidt | 1992 |
| Frank Gotch | 1992 |
| Ed "Stranger" Lewis | 1992 |
| Bob Geigal | 1993 |
| Verne Gagne | 1993 |
| Bruno Sammartino | 1994 |
| Buddy Rogers | 1994 |
| Pat O'Connor | 1995 |
| Gordon Solie | 1995 |
| Antonio Inoki | 1996 |
| Andre the Giant | 1996 |
| Dory Funk Jr | 1996 |
| Bulldog Bob Brown | 1997 |
| Harley Race | 1998 |
| Nick Bockwinkle | 1999 |
| Shohei "Giant" Baba | 1999 |
| Dusty Rhodes | 2000 |
| Roddy Piper | 2000 |
| Terry Funk | 2000 |
| Eddie Graham | 2000 |
| Lou Albano | 2001 |
| Gene Kiniski | 2001 |
| Jack Brisco | 2001 |
| Jerry Brisco | 2001 |
| Mr. Wrestling II | 2002 |
| Gorgeous George | 2002 |
| Killer Kowalski | 2002 |
| Barry Windham | 2003 |
| Owen Hart | 2003 |
| The Vachon Brothers | 2004 |
| Bobo Brazil | 2004 |
| Pat Patterson | 2004 |
| Antonio Rocca | 2004 |
| Dick the Bruser | 2005 |
| The Crusher | 2005 |
| Jesse Ventura | 2005 |
| Paul Bosuch | 2005 |
| Billy Graham | 2005 |
| Ric Flair | 2006 |
| Johnny Valentine | 2006 |
| Bobby Heenan | 2006 |
| The Sheik | 2006 |
| Hulk Hogan | 2007 |
| The Tolos Brothers | 2007 |
| Captain Lou Albano | 2007 |
| Freddie Blassie | 2007 |
| Mark Lewin & Don Curtis | 2008 |
| Bob Backland | 2008 |
| Maurice "Mad Dog" Vachon | 2008 |
| Stu Hart | 2008 |
| The Von Erichs | 2009 |
| Bill Watts | 2009 |
| Ricky Steamboat | 2009 |
| Stan Hansen | 2010 |
| Wahoo McDaniel | 2010 |
| Larry Zbyszko | 2010 |
| Mil Mascaras | 2010 |
| Edouard Carpentier | 2010 |
(Note: "Harley Race" was removed from the Hall of Fame in 1999 to misconduct and reinstated in 2003)
